Bagels and cream cheese are a classic combination, but the right pairing can take your breakfast to the next level. With a variety of bagel flavors and cream cheese spreads to choose from, finding the perfect match is all about balancing textures and tastes. Whether you prefer something sweet, savory, or a little spicy, here’s how to make the best bagel and cream cheese pairings from our bagel shop!
Classic & Simple: Plain Bagel + Any Cream Cheese
A plain bagel is a blank canvas, making it the perfect match for any cream cheese flavor. Whether you’re in the mood for the smoky richness of lox cream cheese, the bold kick of jalapeño, or the sweet touch of maple walnut, this bagel lets the cream cheese shine.
Bold & Savory: Garlic Bagel + Garlic Herb or Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese
For garlic lovers, doubling up on the flavor with garlic herb cream cheese creates a bold and satisfying bite. If you want something rich and hearty, bacon scallion adds a smoky, savory element that pairs beautifully with the garlicky crunch.
Crunchy & Nutty: Sesame Bagel + Scallion or Veggie Cream Cheese
The nuttiness of a sesame bagel pairs well with scallion cream cheese for a fresh, slightly sharp contrast. If you’re looking for something with more texture, veggie cream cheese adds a satisfying crunch with every bite.
Hearty & Wholesome: Multigrain Bagel + Veggie or Plain Cream Cheese
A multigrain bagel offers a slightly nutty, wholesome flavor that pairs well with the crunch of veggie cream cheese. If you prefer to keep it simple, plain cream cheese allows the texture and grains to stand out.
Savory & Spicy: Everything Bagel + Jalapeño or Lox Cream Cheese
Everything bagels are packed with bold flavors from sesame, poppy seeds, garlic, and onion. Jalapeño cream cheese adds a spicy kick, while lox cream cheese complements the bagel’s savory notes with a smooth, smoky finish.
Soft & Sweet: Cinnamon Swirl or Apple Crunch Bagel + Maple Walnut or Strawberry Cream Cheese
For those with a sweet tooth, maple walnut cream cheese enhances the warm, spiced notes of a cinnamon swirl or apple crunch bagel. If you’re craving a fruity touch, strawberry cream cheese brings a fresh, slightly tangy contrast.
Chocolatey & Indulgent: Chocolate Chip Bagel + Plain or Strawberry Cream Cheese
A chocolate chip bagel is already a treat, and pairing it with plain cream cheese lets the sweetness take center stage. If you want to enhance the dessert-like quality, strawberry cream cheese adds a berry-flavored twist.
Bagel Mill | Peterborough Bagel Shop
With so many delicious bagel and cream cheese combinations to choose from, there’s always something new to try. Whether you stick to a classic favorite or mix things up with a bold pairing, the perfect bite is waiting for you here at our bagel shop. Stop by and find your new go-to combo today!
Check us out on Facebook to discover the latest happenings!