Bagels have long been a breakfast staple, best known for classic flavors like plain, sesame, and everything. But over the years, your favorite local cafe and bagel makers around the world have gotten more creative. From sweet to savory—and even downright bizarre—these unique bagel flavors take the beloved baked good to a whole new level.
Rainbow Bagels
First popularized by a Brooklyn bagel shop, these brightly colored bagels became an Instagram sensation in the mid-2010s. Made by twisting vibrant dough together, rainbow bagels are often paired with equally colorful, sweet cream cheese for a dessert-like experience.
Flamin’ Hot Cheetos Bagels
Inspired by the cult-favorite spicy snack, this bagel flavor likely emerged in creative food trends blending junk food with everyday staples. Some bagel shops crush Flamin’ Hot Cheetos into the dough or use them as a coating for an extra-crunchy, fiery bite. These bagels are often paired with a cool ranch or jalapeño cream cheese to balance the heat.
Pickle Bagels
With the rise of pickle-flavored everything, this tangy bagel likely originated in delis or bagel shops. Chopped pickles and dill seasoning are mixed into the dough, and some variations include a pickle-infused cream cheese spread for an extra kick.
S’mores Bagels
Rooted in the classic campfire treat, this bagel emerged as a fun twist on dessert bagels. It’s often made with marshmallow swirls, graham cracker crumbs, and chocolate chips. Toast one up and add a little extra chocolate spread for a decadent treat.
Pizza Bagels (Infused Dough Version)
While traditional pizza bagels date back to the 1950s, the infused dough variation is a newer innovation. Instead of topping a bagel with sauce and cheese, the dough itself is blended with tomato, basil, oregano, and even bits of pepperoni for a more integrated pizza flavor.
Chocolate Chip Bacon Bagels
A sweet-and-savory combination influenced by the rising popularity of bacon-infused desserts, this bagel combines rich chocolate with smoky, crispy bacon bits. The contrast between sweet and salty makes it a unique breakfast treat.
Cotton Candy Bagels
Likely inspired by the viral success of rainbow bagels, these pastel-colored bagels are another visually striking option. Made with a light, sugary flavor, they are often paired with cotton candy-flavored cream cheese for an ultra-sweet experience.
Espresso Bagels
Developed as a way to combine two morning staples—bagels and coffee—these bagels gained traction among caffeine lovers looking for an extra kick. Espresso bagels incorporate real coffee grounds into the dough. This gives them a deep, rich flavor that pairs perfectly with mocha or vanilla cream cheese.
Bagel Mill | Local Cafe
Bagels have come a long way from their traditional roots, and these unique flavors prove that there are no limits to creativity. Whether you’re a fan of sweet, savory, or spicy, there’s a crazy bagel out there for you!
Did we spark your cravings? Stop in and visit us to discover your new favorite bagel combo today!